Saturday, April 11, 2009

Are Opinion Polls Accurate?

Pre-election polls conducted by TV channels and newspapers are interesting because they are never accurate - they are unscientifically conducted, often months before the election and are designed to be opinion makers, not opinion takers...They are conducted to sway voters especially the undecided ones...

For polls to be accurate, the sample should be selected accurately and randomly because all surveys are based on probability sampling... A randomly selected, small percent of a population of people can represent the attitudes, opinions, or projected behavior of the entire population if the sample is selected correctly...But unfortunately with media sponsored surveys, this does not happen...There are many biases...For example, polls are usually conducted by telephone and so people without phones - the majority of Indians - are automatically left out of the sample...Then there is a bias if the interviewee doesn't answer the phone the first time...Ideally, the pollster should try a few times but realistically, it doesn't happen...The questions too are often not objective but leading and biased in favour of the pollster's own political views...The weightage of the sample size is another issue...One of the tricks used is to decrease the weightage of one group to increase the influence of another...Another trick is to decrease the weight of respondants who the pollster thinks are least likely to vote...This manipulation means a respondant who is most likely to vote can be counted twice and a respondant who is least likely to vote can not be counted at all...If polls were scientifically conducted, there wouldn't be so much variation between them...

I am surprised when people are enthused by these media sponsored opinion polls...I would take polls conducted by genuinely independent bodies, who state the methodology used clearly, more seriously...The worst thing about media polls is that they serve very little useful purpose...They try to influence people to vote tactically rather than for who they want...

Comments (14)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Bones, they decide on the conclusion first, and then work out the methods of sampling, etc. to get the desired result! :)
WOW!! have I come to the wrong blog??? This looks gorgeous :))))

Bones I have moved to Wordpress : ) These blogrolls are not updating... I have written three or four posts after the one showing here :(
Anyway I came to invite you participate in a fun contest,
Please Guess and Win the 55 Words Fiction Correct Guess Award
<a href="http://indianhomemaker.wordpress.com/2009/04/11/5..." target="_blank">http://indianhomemaker.wordpress.com/2009/04/11/5...
1 reply · active 833 weeks ago
I was wondering why you weren't posting...
I don't think opinion polls are accurate at all... even if everything else was perfect there is no telling whether the sample respondents answered honestly and seriously, and whether they will vote!!
Absolutely Bones, these so-called opinion polls are designed to "influence people to vote tactically rather than for who they want... " Indian media can barely be distinguished from certain political parties...right now, Priyanka Gandhi is live on NDTV, giving a speech in Amethi!
Opinion polls are of no use at all...
you said it best in the last line ''They try to influence people to vote tactically rather than for who they want... ''
exactly!
And why do we have such a plethora of opinion polls?Its like a deluge!
1 reply · active 833 weeks ago
And each poll is different even when conducted by the same channel!
/* designed to be opinion makers, not opinion takers*/

true one bones... its another political gimmick with the coalition of media... better they are refrain from it.... there are surveys a lot
to be taken in this country :)
Opinion polls can be more accurate if conducted in a more scientific way.But that needs lot of investment in money personal and time.Most media houses are not willing for such an exercise.
A well conducted opinion poll about the public views on important issues [not on number of seats won] can help the political parties to gauge the public mood and act accordingly.It will help the policy makers in Government in formulating changes in Policies
1 reply · active 833 weeks ago
You are right when you say polls should be conducted about public views - I don't see anyone doing that nor do I see political parties discussing important issues...All I read and hear about are alliances for seats...Ultimately, it's about power, nothing else...
Opinion polls are just that :) Opinions.
Absolutely brilliant post. I work in a media research firm and I know how these samples are chosen. The extent of sampling errors hardly bother the researchers. From the are the field team to the research director its only one thing matters...make the report shinny and glossy for the client. Its just a deal...not only in electoral opinion polls but also in even more serious issues like abortion, PDS and poverty eradication programs are also evaluated in the same way...the result …making money out of developmental problems…such a sorry state
I liked the way you exposed the trick of statistics here ....The 'weighting'exersice and wrong /baised/easy available/replacements of samples make the entire process a total waste
Bones, I don't think opinion polls are accurate at all.. As you say 'influence people to vote tactically rather than for who they want... ' I am not even sure, of whether it would be possible to conduct a more scientific poll in a country like India..

Post a new comment

Comments by