Sunday, April 5, 2009

Stressed Out On Poor Street

Have you ever wondered why poverty passes on from generation to generation? Why a majority of poor children underachieve later on in life even when presented with opportunities? The Economist provides some evidence that might explain intergenerational cycles of poverty...

According to researchers, the stress of growing up poor affects the brain which in turn affects the ability to retain and process information...This together with the lack of nutrition and opportunities affects the ability of poor children to compete with richer children as adults...

Edited to add:
Elizabeth Gould, a researcher from Princeton University, thinks chronic stress of living in slums causes the brain to change biologically...

Subsequent experiments [by Gould] have teased out a host of other ways stress can damage the developing brain. For example, if a pregnant rhesus monkey is forced to endure stressful conditions--like being startled by a blaring horn for 10 minutes a day--her children are born with reduced neurogenesis, even if they never actually experience stress once born. This pre-natal trauma, just like trauma endured in infancy, has life-long implications. The offspring of monkeys stressed during pregnancy have smaller hippocampi, suffer from elevated levels of glucocorticoids and display all the classical symptoms of anxiety. Being low in a dominance hierarchy also suppresses neurogenesis. So does living in a bare environment. As a general rule of thumb, a rough life--especially a rough start to life--strongly correlates with lower levels of fresh cells. "Poverty is stress," Gould says, with more than a little passion in her voice. "One thing that always strikes me is that when you ask Americans why the poor are poor, they always say it's because they don't work hard enough, or don't want to do better. They act like poverty is a character issue."
Gould's work implies that the symptoms of poverty are not simply states of mind; they actually warp the mind. Because neurons are designed to reflect their circumstances, not to rise above them, the monotonous stress of living in a slum literally limits the brain.

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Though we do see that poor children may be under achievers even when presented with opportunities, I agree with the comments on this news report that said the results of this study seem inconclusive.

For one thing- stress may be caused by other factors than poverty, too. Suppose a child had parents who were chronically ill. There would be stress but no poverty. Suppose the child's parents were always quarreling or maybe divorced. There would be stress there, too. Would he necessarily be an underachiever, too?

I couldn't make out if the study differentiates between stress caused by poverty and that having some other source.

"In other words, the diminution of memory in the poorer members of their study was entirely explained by stress, rather than by any more general aspect of poverty."- It seems hard to believe that the other aspects of poverty have little effect on the capabilities of the child with regard to memory.

Of course- this is just a layperson's opinion. :)
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Manju, you are probably right...The article hasn't really mentioned what kind of stress biologically affects the brain...It may be that the stress which causes the poor to underachieve could also cause the middle class to under achieve...I'm sure the stress of having an alcoholic and abusive father would be the same on a poor and a rich child...I would think nutrition has a larger role to play in the development of the brain...
I think a similar study in India might yield different results. In 1947, poverty was pervasive in India. Many of today's rich, yuppies and puppies have risen from "poor" backgrounds. Stress and poverty are also possibly not as correlated in India as they are in the affluent West .
2 replies · active 834 weeks ago
Vinod, I agree with you that millions have found their way out of poverty but don't you think stress may play an important role in the way the brain develops?
Yes stress does play a role. But I don't think the poor in India are really stressed...that is a cultural phenomenon.
Bones, I agree with Vinod. I think the Indian psyche also matters. I think we are far more competitive. In the West, I have seen a complacency, wherein people from a poorer background may not feel the 'need' to succeed. In India, I think it might not be so clearcut. Very interesting, nevertheless!
3 replies · active 834 weeks ago
I would think all poor people would want to get out of the cycle of poverty...Even in affluent countries, many of the current rich were born poor...I disagree with you when you say "people from a poorer background may not feel the 'need' to succeed" in the West...As far as complacency is concerned, Indian poor are also complacent...Don't you think blaming one's station in life to fate is a sign of complacency? I've met many people who are doing nothing to improve their lives even when opportunities present themselves...
Bones, I should not have generalised, but let me put what I meant more clearly. In the west, the reason I feel, the complacency is more is probably because the government doles out a lot of benefits. I mean, I have read of teenage girls, getting pregnant, simply because the government will then have to provide them with accomodation. So given that kind of scenario, at least in Britain, I know that the government is trying a lot to get people to start working. On the other hand, in India, the scene is totally different. Most people have no option but to try hard. Of, course, there are complacent people everywhere, just that they might find it easier to be complacent in a weathlier society. In one analysis, they found that most of the lower income groups here where not getting the adequete nutrition because people just took their children to MacDonalds. The fact that they did not even realise that cooking at home is cheaper.
In Europe, Australia and NZ, the benefits to the poor and unemployed are far greater than in the US...Yes, I guess the motivation to work is greatly reduced if the govt. gives out free money...

In these times of recession, McDonald's is doing really well because a large portion of the middle class is downgrading to fast food...Even in the US, obesity amongst the poor is really high because of their fast food diet...
I would agree with Manju. While there may be a high level of co-relation between stress and poverty, it does not prove that a causal relationship exists. Ergo, stress can have many other causes, and is not confined only to the poor. Nutrition, IMHO, is a critical factor, and perhaps a causal relationship exists here.

Cheers.
Chrysalis's avatar

Chrysalis · 834 weeks ago

Stress and its affect on the mind are are irreffutable and its relationship with poverty also exists. But to say that it leads to intergenerational poverty seems to be like passing the buck to the poor. There are many factors which could lead to povery and societal irrresponsibility being a very imporatant one compared to individual resonsibility. Those who have risen from the circumstances of poverty are in fact tougher and more successful than others.
yeah, I tend to agree with Qi here.....
You really pick out great pieces of news/information/trivia and share it with all of us. Thanks for that. Very surprisingly, just yesterday i read a post on someone's blog about how a maid's daughter who failed thrice in a class, was being pulled out of school. And realised that I have often heard about these poor kids failing in school, and I was wondering, why does that happen, when usually no one 'fails' in schools these days, and look what I found out here today.
In the Indian context...

Poverty in the conventional sense may not be stressful if one lives frugally and as poor Indians would normally live. There is also as Vinod refers to, a cultural aspect. The overwhelming sense of its (being poor) inevitability and ascribing it to "karma" also perhaps helps. However, a little of my experience of observing life in Mumbai slums...

A full tummy and the child is probably more willing to listen to teachers, ready to come to school everyday and then make effort to learn, work hard....this is the first step.

The mid-day meal scheme for municipal schools (in Mumbai) run by ISKCON and BMC is a great success. There is widespread monetary support from people for this.

The next is the desire to better their lot. Whilst you may have the laid-back, many see education as a passport to better times. There is an overwhelming desire to be educated, to do "well" in life. I think there is a desire and effort.
What is needed is proper guidance and attitude to change their own circumstances.

This report may be true in an American context. A similar study in India may throw up a very different picture.
Time and again we read about stress a pregnant woman goes through affecting the unborn child adversely. Even our native wisdom says a pregnant woman should be kept in a free environment, kept happy. Perhaps that is why MILs choose exactly that time to harass their DILs!!
I know this is on a different note, but couldn't help putting this down!
Stress affects mental health significantly. Chronic stress can really change the life perception especially in children.

Post a new comment

Comments by