Friday, April 3, 2009

Kolkatans - Who Are These People?

This post was inspired by Chirag's post on Indians...I'm a Bengali although not a Kolkatan and I've always found 'my people' a bit quirky...Here are some observations:
  1. We all know that Bengalis are obsessed with food...What we may not know is that this obsession has reached such a point that nearly half their income is spent on fish, chicken and vegetables...As a result, there's no money left to paint the facade of their houses which adds to the shabbiness of Kolkata...When asked, many Kolkatans say, "Who cares about aesthetics...Anyway, old shabby houses add to the character of the city"
  2. According to Bengalis, there are only three kinds Indians - Bengalis/Oriyas, Hindustanis (North Indians) and Madrasis (South Indians)
  3. Someone should tell Bengali Kolkatans not to speak in Hindi with Bihari and Sikh taxiwallahs...Bengalis will never get the hang of the language no matter how much they try
  4. Bengalis for some reason pronounce 'would'/'wood' as 'ood' (the 'w' is silent)...Even the ones who have attended St.Xaviers College, Kolkata
  5. Bengali babus always eat fish curry-rice before leaving for work...Their work day starts at 11 am and ends promptly at 5 pm with a one hour lunch break in the middle...No wonder nothing gets done in Kolkata
  6. The typical Bengali man always does the vegetable and fish/chicken/mutton shopping...This job is rarely entrusted to a woman or a servant...It is common to see unbathed men with uncombed hair in crushed pajama-kurtas at vegetable and fish shops haggling with vendors early in the morning...Bengalis haven't adapted to the fridge very well as yet...They still feel that all food items should to be bought fresh everyday including butter
  7. Women from Bengal love wearing their sarees six inches above their ankles so that they don't get dirty
  8. Bengali women are dominant and Bengali men are wimps...If you don't believe me, watch Parineeta and Devdas...Devdas, who drank himself to death because his mother forbade him to marry his true love, is idolised by Bengalis...For them, he's the epitome of a true lover...The same is true of Shekhar the hero of Parineeta...Although he does marry his love, he doesn't have the guts to make it public...There are many other stories like these in Bengali literature
  9. Children especially girls have to learn singing preferably Rabindro Sangeet
  10. Never take decorating tips from Bengali women...They have a fetish for doilies and stuffed animals and love decorating their homes with these items...Some even go to the extent of covering their dressing table mirrors with a lace sheet
  11. Bengalis have a fixation for white foreigners (sada chamra)...Blacks are looked down upon except for Barack Obama
  12. Bongs in Kolkata don't have a social life...Kids spend all their free time studying for the Nobel Prize or practicing to be the next Maharaja of Kolkata...Adults spend their time discussing phootball, rabindro sangeet and CPM/Mamatadidi over cups and cups of tea
  13. When Bengalis go out to eat, they will necessarily order a chicken dish...The problem arises when the chicken dish arrives...If all the pieces are not thangs (legs) they start fuming and arguing with the waiter...Why? Their reasoning is: if we order two plates of chicken, we expect 2 legs per plate...They can't seem to understand that a chicken doesn't have only legs
  14. Beware of the Bengali interior decorator/architect...He/She will insist on putting a wash basin in the dining area

Comments (35)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Bones, my daughter has many friends from Bengal at the Research Institute where she studies. Because of them she has learnt to speak fluent Bengali ( Or so they tell me- I would not be able to judge!). I'll ask them what they think of your list. :)
lol... that is so so funny !!!

rotflol....

this is inspiring stuff....

I never like to call myself a gujarati or a kutchi... but i think this post of yours is worth a try... !!!! lol,.....

superb... and yes they are quirky,... lol ! ;)
when i say i dont like to call myself gujarati or kutchi... not that i m ashmaed or nething... I like to call myself as Indian and my religion Indianism...

i have nothing against my fellow gujarati' brothers, sisters and girlfriends !!!

*whew....* close shave....

i need a shave though !! lol
Sraboney, that is a good insight into Kolkatans. A reasonably authentic glimpse of them can be had in Delhi itself. All you have to do is spend half a day around the fish and vegetable market in CR Park!
Bones, No. 5 is true for Malayalis too. Could it be the Communist rule?

There are many similarities between Bengalis and Malayalis. My mom and I are often mistook for being Bengalis. Once a Bengali friend and I were discussing something and our teacher told entire class 'look at them two brains--one Bengali and another Keralite'. They are the most intelligent beings. It was embarrasing though.
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
@Bones! That was hilarious! I am sure a lot of my Bengali friends would certainly agree :) ____@Solilo, Yes, there are loads of similarities between Bengalis and Malayalis.. There is also a legend associated with it, isn't there? And my mother and I are also assumed to be Bengalis by a lots of people.. When we were in Jamshedpur - we always had people coming up and speaking to us in Bengali - same pinch :)____
2 replies · active 834 weeks ago
Great post . Years ago, my brother was in Kolkata , when he encountered this Bengali gentleman . He said this to my brother - "Tum Hindustani hai ? " . My brother, flabbergasted , replied " Haan , par aap bhi to Hindustani hai " . The gentleman - "Tum Hindustani hai . Hum bengali hai " . My brother - "To difference kya hai" . The gentleman " Hum bhartiya hai . Tum bhi bhartiya hai . Lekin hum bengali hai aur tum hindustani hai " . :D I consider myself to be a Banglo-phile .
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Sabyasachi Ghose's avatar

Sabyasachi Ghose · 834 weeks ago

Some comments;1. Especially fried stuff like bread crumb coated fish frry/cops and cutllets all saturated with oli.
4. Pronounciation; It's not zero but giro,ii's not Ztv but Gtv. For the rest listen to Pranab Mukherjee, the Minister EA, who excels in Bengalised English pounciation. Of course, sardars say lion as loin and violin as voilin.
11.All Indians have a fascination for fair skinned people. Actually, we also practise apartheid; the caste system is another example of apartheid.
Haha..that was some deep insight into Bengalis as a group.

Cannot comment much even though I was born in Kolkata and learnt Bengali as a toddler but we never stayed long there and it was always Mumbai after that.
LOL! Bones what a post! Ahve been trying to comemnt desperately coz this was too good to miss! :D
You captured the Bangla essence in one post! ;)
But like Kislay I am a bangla-phile too :D
I love bengali...I keep pestering my bengali friends to teach it to me :D
I'm glad to see that there are so many Banglaphiles...I wasn't aware of 'our' popularity...
Ha ha ha. Nice. Bones, don't mind my saying this, but you don't seem to like Kokatans much. I hate the lazy, overly laid back attitude a lot too, but trust me, having lived in 3 metros of this country, Kolkata still is the only one with some humanity, and sensitivity left. The rest are God damn mechanical. ;) Having just been there, I am kind of in a the nostalgic mode, so am wearing rose tinted glasses regarding the city for now. Also I think kolkata still has a major British Raj hang over!!

And guess what, I was born in Jamshedpur too. Mama bari and all of that. Though I have not been there since 1990, post the death of my grandmother. But I love that city, I have some amazing memories from there.
2 replies · active 834 weeks ago
Goofy Mumma's avatar

Goofy Mumma · 834 weeks ago

Hey I have never heard of 'Hindustani'. New thing learnt!!
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
i have also heard that every kid has to learn a musical instrument or is into some of art - paint or sing or write.
is it true that all baungs especially those who have been raised in calcutta or around always would like to retire in cal even when they have been outside the land for 30 some thing years or so ?
pt no 8. " he does not have the guts to make it public --- Add ( Even after many years ) . But I have to refute the fact that Man are whimps.
pt no 12 -- their famous adda -- that is why nothing gets done !!
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Much as I dislike stereotyping any state or community, I'd have to agree many of these do ring true for a lot of bengalis :)
Btw, I am not a foodie, do not eat fish of any kind (never have since I was in grade six), am fairly conversant in Hindi, do not consider Devdas as the ideal lover, have not learnt Rabindra sangeet, do not wear sarees six inches above the ankle, don't have a doilie/lace fetish, have never haggled about the number of chicken legs in a dish, and I believe I pronounce would/wood without omiting the 'w'! Does that make me any less Bengali? :)
2 replies · active 834 weeks ago
Me too heard some practices of Kolkatans.. while interacting with one friend he said.. he can't take food without non-veg especially Fish... they are really fond of it..
And for the working hours.. its way too low.. One has to work minimum of 8 hrs... but this is very low.. :(
Going by this post, I can safely say Bongs are super observant of the quirkiness of their ilk :)
Chrysalis's avatar

Chrysalis · 834 weeks ago

LOL So true. Though not from Bengal have grown up surrounded by Bengalis and lived in Durgapur for sometime and dad is a Jadavpur product. So I agree with all you have said. When I think of Bengalis I think of studious over competitive kids, robindro sangeet, the 3 must have new dresses for pujo, dominating women def. and food. And yes I also think they love to travel..I have been amazed at hearing " Scenery ta daroon " in non touristy places of my home state (J&K)....and elsewhere too. Love the bong cusine.
1 reply · active 834 weeks ago
Hi lADY, I just got to read this post from my search!!! Loved it and LOL:) I was soo sleepy at work, reading soem documents and all soo happy I bumped into this post!!! Keep writing...
1 reply · active 833 weeks ago
Lol such a funny post enjoyed it thoroughly __Some hilarious comments to____However I don’t agree with the “Shada Chamra” things….It should rather be Bideshi Kolkatan as I have knows are addicted to Negros too…__From Miles Davis, to Charlie parker, to Robert Johnson, to Martin Luther King and all the civil rights protestors….____Enjoyed your blog, and your taste of music too ____I somehow still enjoy being in kolkata, inspite of all the things listed above....__Being a music and movie expeditionary get the best of the music (blues and jazz ),movies and books at cheapest rates!____I am not of kolkatan though____A pakka Sylhety from Silchar____
LOL :D exactly true!!
THE BLOGGER IS SO IGNORANT, SEXIST, HOMOPHOBIC, RACIST BIGOT AND OF COURSE VERY EVIL. STOP HATING BENGALI PEOPLE. IT SEEMS LIKE YOUR PARENTS, FAMILY AND TEACHERS DID NOT TEACH YOU ANY GOOD THINGS, MANNERISM, ANYTHING GOOD. YOU DON'T EVEN KNOW HISTORY OF YOUR OWN COUNTRY! GET A LIFE!

STOP BONGOPHOBIA!

READ THESE: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_Renaissance

JOY MAA MOHA KALI!
JOY MAA DURGA!!
JOY BANGLA!!!
nice post thank you for sharing.

Post a new comment

Comments by